To the Editor: A Level Playing Field
Peter Glassman, owner of Books of Wonder, New York City, which he notes is both a "main street" and online bookseller, writes:
In response to the comments yesterday of Derek Stafford, owner of online bookseller LughnassadhBooks.com, I wish to say that I find his argument spurious. It is no more an uneven playing field for online booksellers to have to pay shipping to their customers than it is for main street booksellers to have to pay a premium for retail space as opposed to the relatively inexpensive cost online booksellers pay for warehouse space. What the "level playing field" refers to is treating all booksellers equally under the law. Obviously, being in Manhattan, I pay a far higher per square foot rent for my store than do my colleagues in suburban New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut. But it's my choice to operate a business here, just as it is Derek Stafford's choice to run an online business. But it is not my choice--or any other bookseller's--to collect sales tax. That is mandated by law. And it is not just a cost to our customers, but a cost to us in tracking, calculating, and paying sales tax, as well as maintaining seven years worth of records concerning them. It is only fair that the law be applied to all businesses equally. That is what the "level playing field" is all about.
In response to the comments yesterday of Derek Stafford, owner of online bookseller LughnassadhBooks.com, I wish to say that I find his argument spurious. It is no more an uneven playing field for online booksellers to have to pay shipping to their customers than it is for main street booksellers to have to pay a premium for retail space as opposed to the relatively inexpensive cost online booksellers pay for warehouse space. What the "level playing field" refers to is treating all booksellers equally under the law. Obviously, being in Manhattan, I pay a far higher per square foot rent for my store than do my colleagues in suburban New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut. But it's my choice to operate a business here, just as it is Derek Stafford's choice to run an online business. But it is not my choice--or any other bookseller's--to collect sales tax. That is mandated by law. And it is not just a cost to our customers, but a cost to us in tracking, calculating, and paying sales tax, as well as maintaining seven years worth of records concerning them. It is only fair that the law be applied to all businesses equally. That is what the "level playing field" is all about.