A Million Little Finesses; Oprah Offers Support
Watching James Frey on Larry King Live last night was a little like
listening to Judge Samuel Alito before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
His general statements sounded reasonable, but he avoided answering
questions about particular issues. For example, when King showed a tape
with several specific charges and asked him to rebut them, Frey said
simply, "I
wasn't listening." Frey called the memoir in the tradition of
Hemingway, Fitzgerald, Kerouac and Bukowski, although King pointed out
that their works were fiction.
Frey repeated several times that "less than 5% of the book is disputed" and that "it's a selective recollection of my life. It's my story and a truthful retelling of that story. It's the essential truth of my life." He claimed to have previously acknowledged changing certain facts to protect people and simplify events, but said it wasn't "fair to classify it as fiction."
Still, he affirmed that the book was originally shopped as fiction and had no explanation for why it was published as nonfiction. He added that in the future he will not write "about myself."
The show wound down unremarkably until a minute before its scheduled end, when Oprah Winfrey, who until last night had been publicly silent, called in and expressed her support for Frey and particularly for A Million Little Pieces. "We support the book because we recognize hundreds of thousands of people have been saved by this book." She scorned some of the criticism, saying the controversy was "much ado about nothing." In "memoirs, many days and names and times have been compressed," she continued. In the case of A Million Little Pieces, "the underlying message of redemption still resonates with me."
If anything was wrong or anyone at fault, it was the publisher, she seemed to indicate. "I rely on publishers to define the category a book falls in and the authenticity of the work," she said. "For me, the bigger question is what this means for the publishing world and the memoir category."
---
In other Frey fray news, a Reuters story yesterday that Random House was offering a special refund on copies of A Million Little Pieces to unhappy readers who bought the book directly from the publisher turned out not to be true--in the sense that this might be a quiet admission of guilt by Random. The company said it has a longstanding policy of offering refunds on any title bought directly.
The Hollywood Reporter (via the Book Standard) reported on the possible repercussions of the controversy on films based on books by Frey and the week's other scandal-plagued "author," J.T. Leroy. The film version of A Million Little Pieces, the journal said, might need "a rehab of its own."
Frey repeated several times that "less than 5% of the book is disputed" and that "it's a selective recollection of my life. It's my story and a truthful retelling of that story. It's the essential truth of my life." He claimed to have previously acknowledged changing certain facts to protect people and simplify events, but said it wasn't "fair to classify it as fiction."
Still, he affirmed that the book was originally shopped as fiction and had no explanation for why it was published as nonfiction. He added that in the future he will not write "about myself."
The show wound down unremarkably until a minute before its scheduled end, when Oprah Winfrey, who until last night had been publicly silent, called in and expressed her support for Frey and particularly for A Million Little Pieces. "We support the book because we recognize hundreds of thousands of people have been saved by this book." She scorned some of the criticism, saying the controversy was "much ado about nothing." In "memoirs, many days and names and times have been compressed," she continued. In the case of A Million Little Pieces, "the underlying message of redemption still resonates with me."
If anything was wrong or anyone at fault, it was the publisher, she seemed to indicate. "I rely on publishers to define the category a book falls in and the authenticity of the work," she said. "For me, the bigger question is what this means for the publishing world and the memoir category."
---
In other Frey fray news, a Reuters story yesterday that Random House was offering a special refund on copies of A Million Little Pieces to unhappy readers who bought the book directly from the publisher turned out not to be true--in the sense that this might be a quiet admission of guilt by Random. The company said it has a longstanding policy of offering refunds on any title bought directly.
The Hollywood Reporter (via the Book Standard) reported on the possible repercussions of the controversy on films based on books by Frey and the week's other scandal-plagued "author," J.T. Leroy. The film version of A Million Little Pieces, the journal said, might need "a rehab of its own."